I read Erica Bauermeister’s The Scent Keeper for a book club discussion. There was a lot I loved about this book, especially early on: how magical things seemed when Emmeline was viewing things as a child, and how that gently shifted as she matured; the mystery of why she and her father were on this island, and how she didn’t know anything about the rest of the world; the way scent can trigger memories and feelings.
The book fizzled out in the last third, though. What had felt like hints of magical realism didn’t carry that same intrigue. There was more telling than showing, characters started to become flat and one-dimensional, and things wrapped up far too quickly and neatly, with a cheesy epilogue.
Overall, still a good read. I just wish the last third of the book had contained the same magic and character development as the rest of the book.